The new Wilson Hypotheses

Back in 2018, Ian Wilson published ‘The Turin Shroud: New Facts and a New Historical Theory’ in the BSTS Newsletter, and in 2022, he contributed a chapter called ‘The image of Edessa: an Evolving Understanding through Art and History’, to Mark Guscin’s book, ‘Recent Studies on the Image of Edessa.’ In 2025, another article for the BSTS appeared, called ‘A Strange Case of Dark Age Forgery’, then in 2026 he delivered a presentation on his new hypothesis (remotely, as he lives in Australia), to the BSTS Conference on the Shroud in Blackburn Cathedral. This was entitled ‘Introducing a Brand-New Scenario for the ‘Middle Years’ of the Shroud’s History’. His ideas are quite complex and detailed, and divide into three or four distinct sections, which is why I have referred to them as hypotheses rather than a single hypothesis. As usual, I have been attempting to follow the hypotheses from primary sources, although, as Wilson admits, they are both fragmentary and inconclusive. In my opinion, though, where they can be studied in any depth, not only do they not support his hypotheses, but seem to me to be evidence against it.

While I was gradually assembling this post, Jack Markwardt has gone public with his own assessment of one area of Wilson’s hypotheses, and although we differ in our own ideas in almost every way, we both agree that the Constantinople-Jerusalem-Cyprus-Lirey route is, so far, insufficiently evidenced to be at all convincing. Markwardt’s review appeared on 13 November on a Real Seekers podcast, and stimulated me to tidy up and publish my own ideas, although he promises two further instalments and Wilson promises a book, any or all of which may stimulate radical revision. The following then may turn out to be a ‘work-in-progress’ of my own. It is a synthesis of all four of Wilson’s latest contributions to Shroud scholarship, of which the second is the most copiously referenced.

Assuming, as he has for years, that the Image of Edessa was the Shroud, folded up to expose only the face, Wilson speculates that when it was given by one Christian faction to another, in Edessa in about 700, as security for a loan, it was copied, and both versions re-covered by the close-fitting gold surround we see on alleged Veronicas today, whose iconography derives from this period. However, in the 10th century, in Constantinople, it was opened up, and the whole ‘landscape format’ head section revealed. This became new standard depiction of the Mandylion. However a violent earthquake in 989 was taken as a sign of wrath at the exposure of the relic, such that it was re-sealed in its reliquary, never to be seen again by anybody but, possibly, the emperor, who had the only key. When, hundreds of years later, in 1534, the reliquary, now part of the Louis IX collection in the Sainte Chapelle in Paris, was opened and inspected, it was found to be empty.

Since only the emperor had access to this Mandylion after 989, Wilson speculates that Manuel I Komnenos (born 1118, reign 1143 – 1180) would be a good choice as a possible remover of the cloth from its case. He might have done so, thinks Wilson, to send it secretly to King Baldwin of Jerusalem (reign 1174 – 1185), as a protective palladium against an increasingly threatening Islamic incursion, and in an attempt to cure the young king’s leprosy. He might have chosen Leontios of Patmos, who was Patriarch of Jerusalem from 1170 to 1190, to take the relic to Jerusalem when he was sent, by Manuel, to visit the city in 1177, an unusual mission as imperial Orthodox hierarchy were generally forbidden to enter it by the resident Roman hierarchy. According to Wilson, the plan was for Leontios to arrive incognito at Acre, perform some healing miracles with the aid of the Shroud, and thus be invited to the Royal Court to see if he could do the same with Baldwin, without anyone knowing who he was. Unfortunately his identity leaked out and attempts were made to assassinate him as soon as he arrived. In desperation Leontios entrusted the Shroud to King Baldwin’s step-mother, the dowager Queen Maria Komnene (born 1154), who was Manuel’s great niece. She took advantage of a formal banquet in honour of Philip I Count of Flanders, who visited Baldwin in August 1177, to present the king with the Shroud, concealed under or within “a dish of tempting delicacies.”

Wilson associates this banquet and the secret presentation of the Shroud to King Baldwin, with a poem by Chrétien de Troyes composed soon after Count Philip’s return to Flanders, in which the young Arthurian knight Perceval, dining at the court of the crippled Fisher King, watches a procession “in which a beautifully dressed young woman carries in a grail, or dish, secretly containing an ultra-holy object intended to cure the king of his infirmity.” Could this be an allusion to the dowager queen step-mother carrying a secret cure to king Baldwin of Jerusalem?

Although it failed to cure Baldwin, Wilson contends that the Shroud would have been left in Jerusalem as spiritual protection against the Saracens after Philip and Leontios had left, its guardian being the dowager Queen Maria. However, after initial success, and the defeat of Salah ad-din at the battle of Montgisard in November 1177, the Christians of the Holy Land were gradually crushed by a steady war of attrition that resulted in the capture of Jerusalem ten years later. Since she was an Orthodox rather than a Roman Christian Salah ad-Din allowed Queen Maria to retreat to the Templar stronghold at Acre, to whom she entrusted the Shroud. When even Acre finally fell, in 1291, the Templars and their treasures retreated to Cyprus.

Fifteen years later, the Templars had lost favour among the crowned heads of Europe, most of whom were deeply in debt to them both financially and socially, and the French King Philip IV instigated a putsch against their leaders which eventually exterminated the order completely. The Shroud, according to Wilson, had been taken from Cyprus to a castle in Vostitza, Greece, which was held from about 1315 by Dreux de Charny, the elder brother of Geoffrey de Charny (1306-1356), who “has effectively been confirmed” as being from the same family as the Geoffrey de Charney who was third in the Templar hierarchy and burned at the stake with leader Jacques de Molay in 1314. Wilson confidently asserts that “the container in which the cloth came to the ‘Shroud’ Geoffrey de Charney is well-documented: a simple, cypress wood box decorated only with the Charny family heraldry, which would have provided a family address in France to which the cloth could be sent in the event of ‘Templar Draper’ Geoffrey de Charney’s death.”

So far, so interesting. It’s a good story, and not entirely implausible, although there are a few ‘plot-holes’. The question is, however, whether the sources adduced to support all this supposition actually do so, or if more has to be read into them than they can really bear.

=======================================

THREE IDENTICAL VERSIONS OF THE IMAGE OF EDESSA

This story begins with the collapse of part of the Hagia Sophia cathedral in Edessa as a consequence of an earthquake in 689 AD. Although the population was largely Christian, the city was ruled by a Moslem elite who regarded them very much as an underclass. Nevertheless, Caliph Mu’awiya oversaw the rebuilding of the Hagia Sophia, an expensive undertaking which financially crippled the Melkites, the Greek-speaking Christian sect who controlled it. Ruthlessly taxed by Mu’awiya’s successor, Abd al-Malik, the Melkites sought a loan from the Syrian-speaking Monophysites, whom they despised, in the person of the very wealthy Athanasius bar Gumaye. He was happy to lend them 5000 dinars, provided they gave him the Image of Edessa, of whom they were they keepers, as security. While in Athanasius’ possession, he had it copied so precisely that it was impossible to tell the difference, returned the copy to the Melkites upon repayment of the loan, and kept the original, eventually depositing it in a Baptistery built expressly for that purpose.

The sources for this story are fragmentary. Wilson’s source is J.B. Segal’s 1970 book, ‘Edessa, the Blessed City’, which in turn draws from a ‘Chronique de Michel le Syrien’, a four-volume History of the World from Adam to the late 12th century. Michel says he got his information from the writings of Dionysius of Tel Mahre (died 845) who in turn was told it by his grandfather.

According to Segal, another identical copy was also made by the Nestorians, another Christian sect, so that when the Byzantine General John Kourkouas arrived before Edessa to obtain the image for Constantinople, he was actually presented with three. On the other hand, the Narratio de Imagine Edessena (about 944), lists the original, the Nestorian copy, and a third made to deceive the Persian King Khosrow I after he had besieged Edessa in 544. Having failed, he retired from the city, but shortly afterwards begged the Edessans to send him the image to help drive out a demon from his possessed daughter. The Edessans sent the fake, but it fooled the demon anyway and Khosrow’s daughter was cured.

None of this makes a lot of sense in terms of the Shroud. Authenticists insist that it is impossible to copy, and contains no paint, so how two or three identical replicas were made in the 6th century presents a serious obstacle to the idea that the Image and the Shroud were the same.

It is Wilson’s conjecture that to facilitate copying, the Image, already folded tetradiplon so that only the face was visible, was now closely encased in a gold revetment, and that copies looking like it, such as those of Genoa and Rome (and a few more he doesn’t mention) stem from that time, and before the Image’s true nature was revealed in Constantinople. Its only problem is that until recently, there was no evidence that any of these revetted images were made before, or copied from something else made before, the middle of the 10th century. Here is a selection, from Rome, Vienna, Genoa and Spain:

Wilson hopes he has found some support for his hypothesis by an article on medieval coinage by Anna Gannon,1 illustrated by an Anglo-Saxon sceat from the 7th century:

This, Wilson thinks, features “a face of Jesus with a shape strikingly similar to the so distinctively shaped contour that surrounds the three holy faces.” But does it? It is entirely characteristic of authenticist claims, and particularly so of numismatic ones, to grab one hopeful candidate from a huge pile of similar examples, and claim that because that one resembles some characteristics of the Shroud one hopes to match, therefore it must have been modelled on them. We have been here before.

Here are a few more similar Sceatta Series BZ Type 29b:

Of all those I can find on the internet, only the one picked out by Gannon shows a tripartite beard. Furthermore, there is another series of Anglo-Saxon late 7th century coins (Series Z) which may also show the head of Christ, which seem even less likely derive from the revetted images:

These have usually been understood as probably Wotan or Odin, chief of the Scandinavian/Germanic gods, but Gannon illustrates one from Series Z with crosses over the top of the head, .

Even given that at least some of these derive from an image of Christ rather than Wotan, the image from which this iconography derives is much more likely to be the image brought to Britain in 597 by St Augustine (as mentioned by Bede) than anything transported from Constantinople. Sadly we know nothing of what it looked like.

=======================================

WHO STOLE THE SHROUD?

If (and it’s a very big if) the reliquary containing the Shroud was empty when it was sent to Paris as part of Louis IX’s relic hoard, who removed it? This next phase rests on two sources, the inventories of the relic collection in the Sainte Chapelle and the Tarragona 55 manuscript.

Everything hinges on the relic collection sent to Louis IX of France by Baldwin II of Constantinople, round about 1240. Was the Shroud of Turin included among the relics, and if so, which one was it, and is there evidence that it was removed?

The official inventory, made in 1247, lists item 8: “Sanctam toellam, tabulae insertam” and item 16: “Partem sudarii quo involutum fuit corpus ejus in sepulchro.”2 Neither of these descriptions fits the Shroud comfortably, although the second seems more obviously to be describing a burial cloth than the first. The ‘holy towel’ seems to describe the Mandylion, which could only be the Shroud if one equates the two. Wilson’s hypothesis is that the ‘sanctam toellam’ was not, in fact, ‘tabulae insertam’, but had been secretly extracted, and nobody checked. “From an inventory of 1534 it does appear that on this late occasion someone must have looked inside its casket properly to check on its contents. However, this was only to find a face seemingly painted on the casket’s floor, also some gold plates, perhaps from the fretwork surround, but definitely no ‘toellam’.” I don’t think this is an accurate translation nor a justified interpretation of the detailed description of the treasurer’s efforts to reconcile the collection he found with the list made three hundred years earlier. A part of the true cross and three skulls were missing from their reliquaries but accounted for, and another skull fragment had been moved into a different box. In another box they found a “voile de Nostre Dame,” which was not on the original list. My paraphrase of what they found of the ‘sanctam toellam’ reads: “As for item eight, originally described as the ‘sanctam toellam tabulae inserta,’ it was found with some difficulty in a large reliquary. It had been firmly covered by a board embellished in gilt-silver with an opening shaped like the image, which was completely surrounded by it.” This would almost certainly be one of the many Veronica-style icons as illustrated above.

Still, experts in Renaissance French can compare my version with the original: “Et au regard du huitième article, contenant la trelle inserée à la table, après plusieurs difficultés, a esté finallement trouvée en un grand reliquaire et tableau garny d’argent surdoré, où y a apparence d’une effigie, ladite trelle comme consommée contre ledit tableau, autour, environ et dans ladite effigie.”

The medieval Latin word ‘toellam’ has been replaced by the medieval French word ‘trelle,’ neither of which is either common or easily translated. The first is a Latinised version of a Frankish word meaning ‘towel’, and the second seems (albeit remotely) associated with the Latin ‘trichlia’, meaning ‘arbour’, (i.e. trellis-work). Subsequent inventories seem to describe this item as “La veronique” (c.1550), “La représentation de la sainte face de Notre Seigneur, ou la Véronique” (1740), and “Une sainte face” (1791), which do not suggest an empty container. Meanwhile the burial cloth appears as “Une partie du suaire auquel fut envelopé son corps au sepulchre (1534), “De sindone Domini” (c.1550), “”De sindone Domini” (1740) and “Du saint suaire” (1791).

All in all I can’t agree that these descriptions suggest that the Mandylion was missing.

But supposing it was, who took it? According to Wilson, the Tarragona Manuscript3 says that only the emperor had access to the Mandylion/Shroud, having been locked away after an earthquake which the hierarchy of Constantinople attributed to the wrath of God at too profligate a display. The relevant passage is: “Hoc linteum preciosissimum domini Ihesu vultu et attactu insignitum maiori pre ceteris reliquiis in palatio veneracione observatur, maiori diligentia tenetur ita ut semper sit clausum aureo vase et obfirmatum diligentissime. Et cum cetere omnes reliquie palacii cunctis quibusque temporibus ostendantur fidelibus, istud linteum in quo continetur nostri Redemptoris vultus figuratus nulli demonstratur, nulli aperitur, nec ipsi Constantinopolitano imperatori.” Note the last sentence: “And while all the other relics in the palace are displayed to the faithful at various times, this cloth, which bears the image of our Redeemer’s face, is never shown or revealed to anyone, not even to the Emperor of Constantinople himself.“

=======================================

THE IMAGE OF CHRIST AS A PALLADIUM

Why send the Mandylion/Shroud to Jerusalem? Wilson claims that it could have been used as a palladium, an apotropaic object paraded around a city, through the ranks of an army or on the walls overlooking besiegers to help bring divine assistance to the beleaguered inhabitants. This is a bit far-fetched. Although it was clearly an object of immense significance before (and during) its arrival in Constantinople, it quickly faded into obscurity. In 1036 it was part of a procession of numerous relics processed through the streets to try to alleviate a drought, with the result that the city was devastated by such a severe hailstorm that a famine broke out requiring a hundred thousand bushels of corn to be bought from the Greeks.4 Except in passing mentions by visiting pilgrims, the image and its associated tile are scarcely heard of again. If the Tarragona Manuscript is anything to go by, it brought nothing but calamity.

Similarly, the Image of Camuliana, or Image of God Incarnate, and an equally effective copy of it, is described as being used as a palladium up to the siege of Constantinople in 626, but is never heard of again. It is usually supposed to have been destroyed during the 8th – 9th century iconoclasm.

“Because no one reported it being used as a protection device during the two Crusader sieges of 1203/4, when Constantinople was ruled by the usurper Angelos dynasty, it would seem to have been removed before then. Given that only an emperor could open the reliquary, could it have been one of the emperors of the preceding Komnenos dynasty?” In a word, no. There was, as it happens, a well-known palladium of Constantinople, the Theotokos Hodegetria, a painting of the Virgin and Child allegedly by St Luke. This was believed to have helped defeat the Sassanids in 626, Umar II in 718 and Svjatoslav of Kiev in 971, and to have survived the sack of the city by the Crusaders in 1204. It was still being paraded around the city in the 15th century. It is never mentioned in connection with the Mandylion.

=======================================

MANUEL – LEONTIOS – MARIA – BALDWIN

We begin with a few accepted historical facts:

a). 1099. The First Crusade recaptured Jerusalem and some nearby territory for the Christians, after four hundred years of Moslem occupation, electing a king.
b). 1143. Manuel I Komnenos became the Byzantine Emperor.
c). 1144. Edessa was recaptured by the Moslems and its churches razed to the ground.
d). 1167. King Amalric of Jerusalem took Maria Komnene, great-niece of Emperor Manuel, as his second wife.
e). 1174. Amalric died, and was replaced by his 13-year-old son, Baldwin IV, who suffered from leprosy.
f). 1176. Manuel suffered a serious defeat by the Moslems at the Battle of Myriokephalon.

According to Wilson, Manuel became increasingly alarmed for the fate of (Roman Christian) Jerusalem as a result of this defeat, but did not want to send troops for fear of antagonising his (Orthodox Christian) subjects in Constantinople. Is this likely? The same Moslem army was almost completely destroyed a few years later at the Battle of Hyelion and Leimocheir, and Manuel himself was planning to send an armada to attack Salah ad-Din in Egypt in 1177.

“What about deploying the Sudary [Wilson’s name for the Image of Edessa / Shroud]? It had long protected Edessa until one of Manuel’s predecessors had snatched it from the city, with the appalling consequences that had scarred the start of his own reign.”

This is a little disingenuous. Even if it is true that the Image had protected the city from the Persians in 544, it hadn’t stopped Khosrow I capturing it in 609 or, after a brief Byzantine re-occupation, it being permanently Moslem from 638 until 1098, when it was recaptured by the Crusaders on their way to Jerusalem.

The other reason for sending the Image of Edessa to Baldwin could have been that, just as it had allegedly cured King Abgar of Edessa of leprosy, it might do the same for Baldwin.

At this point the rather obscure Leontios of Patmos enters the script, and we are hard put to find anything contemporary about him beyond the hagiographical biography of his disciple Theodosius Goudelis.5 Wilson’s account of his visit to the Holy Land differs from this in interesting respects.

“In 1177, and quite extraordinarily, Manuel directly sent Leontios to Jerusalem, the strategy for overcoming Roman Catholic opposition seeming to have been for him to arrive incognito at the port of Acre, and perform some healings in the surrounding countryside, which he duly did; the hope being that news of these might prompt an invitation to attend king Baldwin at the Jerusalem court without anyone knowing who he was, any Abgar-like healing miracle using the Sudary surely securing his acceptance, and Jerusalem’s future as a Christian city. Leontius’s patriarchal identity evidently leaked out, immediately provoking Jerusalem’s Roman Catholic patriarch not only to block him from getting anywhere near Jerusalem, but even to attempt to assassinate him.”

But Leontios did not arrive incognito. According to his biographer he was warmly greeted by the Orthodox population of Acre. Nor was he blocked from going to Jerusalem. According to Goudelis it was there that the assassination attempt occurred, which was foiled by the miracle of the assassins not being able to find his door. Although he was not allowed to preside over services at the Holy Sepulchre, he was able to pray there privately, and was permitted to minister to the Orthodox community in other less important churches. He may even have stayed to conduct official business, as evidenced by the discovery of a lead seal with the inscription ‘Leontios, by the Grace of God, Patriarch of Jerusalem,’ a few yards from the Holy Sepulchre, in 2020.6

It is true that Philip of Flanders visited Jerusalem in 1177, and that on his return home he commissioned Chrétien de Troyes to write an epic poem about an Arthurian hero, Perceval, based on a story he himself provided. However there is no evidence of any meeting between Leontios and dowager Queen Maria (which Goudelis would surely have included if it had occurred), no evidence of a formal banquet for Philip at which Maria presented Baldwin with the Shroud, and no evidence that Maria subsequently gave anything to the Knights Templar at Acre.

Finding allusions to actual events in Grail fiction has been a serious field of study since the 1940s, but Helen Adolf, who wrote an influential paper about Perceval in 1943, thought that the fictitious banquet had its origins in the known coronation banquet of Philip II, not the unknown banquet postulated by Wilson. It is not possible to refute the story completely, of course, because absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, but it is also not evidence of presence either.

A hundred years later (1291) the last of the Crusader coastal strongholds fell to the Saracens and the Holy Land ceased to be Christian. At no point was any palladium invoked to save them. All the Christian treasures and portable possessions were either lost or had to be moved. In a completely evidence-free wilderness, Wilson can suppose that the Shroud, at some point extracted from its closely surrounding border of gold, went with the Templars to Limassol, Cyprus, and then – why not? – to Vostitza on the north coast of the Peloponnese, where it acquired a new container, “a simple Cyprus wood box decorated only with the Charney family heraldry.”

In 1316, Dreux de Charny, older brother of Geoffroi (who died at Poitiers in 1356), married the heiress to Vostitza, Agnès de Charpigny. There is no evidence that he was a Templar, or related to Geoffrey de Charney (who was burnt at the stake in 1314). And Wilson’s assertion that “that the two Geoffrey de Charnys were from the same family has effectively been confirmed, thanks to a completely independent recent study by Dr Joachim Shenk,” is very much over-stating Shenk’s actual findings.

The description of the reliquary appears to come from Jean-Jacques Chifflet’s book ‘De Linteis Sepulchralibus Christi Servatoris Crisis Historica,’ published in 1624. To claim that it is “well-documented” that this was how the Shroud came to Geoffrey de Charny is bold indeed, especially as the Latin used to illustrate the slide in which the claim is made is mistranslated. The quote is: “arca cypressina, que hodieque extat in Villariosexel apud Marchionem de Varambon, illius loci Dominum, in qua creditur asservatum quondam scriniolum Charniensi insignitum stemmate, sacram Sindonem capiens.” A box of cypress wood, still extant in Villersexel with its Lord the Marquis de Varambon, which it is believed once held a little reliquary, decorated with the Charny arms, containing the sacred Shroud.”

Finally, the leap from Dreux to his younger brother Geoffrey is confused by the fact that nothing at all in Geoffrey’s writings, or in anybody’s writings to Geoffrey, that we know of, mentions a shroud, an image of Christ or anything like it. Wilson accounts for this by some kind of oath of secrecy made by Geoffrey to his Templar cousins, which was only broken by his widow after he died. Needless to say there is no evidence for this, nor really any justification for it.

=======================================

To be fair to Wilson, he has always been at pains to insist that his ideas are avenues to explore rather than done deals, and the penultimate paragraph of his first paper is worth quoting in full.

“Needing to be very firmly repeated is that the radically fresh theorising that has been put forward here remains a tentatively advanced ‘work in progress’ rather than anything to be to be trumpeted to the world-at-large as some sensational new historical fact. Quietly circulated amongst interested parties the theorising will undoubtedly undergo future corrections, modifications and adjustments by myself – quite aside from by others – perhaps even needing to be abandoned altogether.”

I think the intervening eight years have strengthened Wilson’s confidence in his ‘revision’ of Shroud history, but I’m sure he is just as interested in consolidating it with further research as ever, and will be grateful for Markwardt’s, and my, endeavours.

=======================================

1). ‘Coins, images and tales from the Holy Land: Questions of Theology and Orthodoxy’, Anna Gannon, academia.edu, 2011

2). In e.g. ‘The Sequences in De Sanctis Reliquiis as Sainte-Chapelle Inventories,’ Karen Gould, Medieval Studies, Vol 43, 1981, and ‘Le Trésor de la Sainte-Chapelle,’ Alexandre Vidier, Mémoires de la Société de l’Histoire de Paris et de l’Île-de-France, Vols 34 – 36, 1908

3). ‘Une Description de Constantinople dans le Tarragonensis 55,’ Krijnie N. Ciggaar, Revue des Études Byzantines, 1995

4). Recounted by John Skylitzes (Synopsis Historion, c.1080)

5). ‘The Life of Leontios, Patriarch of Jerusalem’, by Theodosius Goudelis, translated by Dimitris Tsougarakis, 1993

6). ‘A Unique Crusader-Period Lead Seal from the Old City of Jerusalem’, Robert Kool and Annette Landes-Nagar, ‘Atiqot, 2023

Comments

  1. It seems a curious move by Authenticists to claim that there were multiple identical versions of the shroud circulating around Europe and the Middle East during the Middle Ages. It raises the obvious question: how do we know we have the right one?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *